Navigating Darkness, Embrace Truth: If I were Rust Cohle’s Therapist
A MENtal Strength series article—click here for article home page.
In the gritty world of HBO’s True Detective, Rust Cohle emerges as a captivating enigma, a character shaped by profound grief, haunting trauma, and a desire for truth in a universe he sees as bleak. Rust was ordered to get therapy, a common trope in TV shows where cops are often closed off to the idea. Rust, who already voiced his negative view of therapy, embodies this trope perfectly. It makes sense to expect nothing to come from forcing Rust into therapy, but if I were assigned as his therapist…
… I feel pretty confident we’d be a good fit.
My approach would leverage the remarkable strengths he brings while inviting self-awareness to areas of his life where his strengths aren’t yet shining brightly. And I think a great deal of resistance from him would dissolve when he realizes that I’m not trying to take away any of what he’s holding onto—I’d be helping more fully embrace his values and his beliefs.
Understanding Rust’s Complexity
Rust Cohle, brilliantly portrayed by Matthew McConaughey, embodies a complex blend of existential nihilism and deeply buried emotional wounds. His journey is marked by complicated grief over the loss of his daughter and the psychological scars accumulated through years of law enforcement in the heart of darkness.
Approaching Rust’s mandated counseling, I would anticipate his skepticism and resistance. His persona as a stoic lone wolf belies a desire to be heard and understood on his own terms. My role would not be to mold him into someone new but to facilitate a journey towards becoming more authentically himself, shedding fear-based defenses that stunt his growth. Supporting clients in embracing their self-truth is effective and often motivates clients who would otherwise feel hesitant, as Rust likely would.
Fostering Appreciation of Strengths
One crucial way to encourage Rust to better embrace his values is by expressing genuine appreciation for his strengths. When we support him in recognizing his strengths, such as his courage in acknowledging darkness, he becomes more willing to embody those strengths in other aspects of his life. For example, Rust courageously faces darkness in his work as a detective but struggles to bring that same courage to his personal relationships. By working with his strengths and values, we can help him apply them to areas where he is struggling.
Dialogue through Philosophy and Depth
Rust’s affinity for philosophical discourse serves as a gateway to connect deeply with him. Engaging with existential themes and thinkers like Nietzsche would not only resonate with his intellectual curiosity but also dismantle barriers he erects to shield himself from emotional intimacy. Clients can feel resistance when they are afraid of being judged or having something taken away from them, making this philosophical dialogue crucial for building trust.
Authentic Validation
I would show him my own enthusiasm for the ideas he cares about. I genuinely enjoy talking about Nietzche, and I believe many people have some nihilism in their shadows that they’d do well to digest. I wouldn’t trick him into thinking I’m a kindred spirit–I’d actually bring forth the parts of me that do make me a kindred spirit to him. By engaging with his unique worldview without judgment, I would naturally foster a therapeutic alliance grounded in mutual respect and understanding. This approach helps clients more fully embrace their true selves, leading to greater authenticity and self-acceptance.
Challenging Cognitive Barriers
Challenging Rust’s cognitive defenses, I would gently guide him to confront unresolved traumas and the limitations imposed by his self-imposed isolation. By reframing healing as a pathway to enhancing his ability to live in alignment with his values, I aim to empower Rust towards a more fulfilling existence. Good therapy helps people more fully embrace their true selves. Good therapy for Rust Cohle will help him become more Rust, not less Rust.
Embracing Risk and Authenticity
Acknowledging the risks inherent in our therapeutic journey, I would remain steadfast in my authenticity. My approach values transparency and challenges assumptions, creating a space where Rust can explore his vulnerabilities and strengths without fear of judgment. Working with a client’s strengths and values means appreciating their strengths and helping them apply these strengths to areas where they are struggling.
Impact and Success in Counseling
In my practice, success is measured not by imposing change but by empowering clients to live authentically and purposefully, on their own terms. For individuals like Rust, who harbor mistrust and profound anger, fostering an environment of openness and genuine dialogue often leads to breakthroughs unseen in previous therapeutic encounters.
Navigating the Dark
Counseling Rust Cohle demands a therapeutic approach rooted in empathy, intellectual engagement, and a steadfast commitment to authenticity. By navigating his darkness with compassion and understanding, my goal would be to illuminate a path towards healing and self-empowerment, encouraging him to embody his true self and values.
Counseling Rust Cohle would be a profound exploration into the depths of human resilience and the complexities of psychological healing. By honoring his intellect, validating his experiences, and challenging cognitive distortions, my aim is to facilitate a transformative journey towards self-discovery and inner peace. This approach can be applied not only to Rust but to anyone seeking to become more authentically themselves, embracing their strengths and values to navigate their own darkness.
Michael Giles LCSW is a psychotherapist who specializes in helping men overcoming anxiety, heal from trauma, and repair their relationships.
Click here to schedule a consultation.
Click here to read about his book, Relationship Repair for Men: Counterintuitive behaviors that restore love to struggling relationships.
Click here to return to the articles homepage.
